Kristina and I visit the Main Street of Bowling Green, Ohio often. There is a variety of restaurants with their different cuisines. Look for other reviews for Beckett's Burger Bar and future reviews here as well. We returned to the Easy Street Cafe as despite having been here before, we never had a burger. Kristina had the Easystreet Burger...check out her review as well. Today I am reviewing East Street Cafe's Pizza Burger.
Before I get started, sometimes someone just wants a standard burger. Normal toppings of lettuce, tomato, mayo/ketchup, and cheese. From what we saw on our menu, they did not offer a standard burger to order. So I chose a pizza burger as a second option.
Their toppings were a pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni. The cheese was well-distributed, but the pepperoni was gathered in the middle like it was hiding the weakest pepperoni from being devoured first. When you make a pizza burger, you are serving two masters. You are making a burger and the burger needs to be done right as well as the pizza itself needs to be addressed. Much like a pizza, the sauce can make or break the pizza and this sauce smashed the burger in a negative way. The sauce tasted like a bland ketchup with no flavor. Their marinara for the mozzarella sticks had more flavor than this. The sauce also was very runny that much of the toppings fell off the burger after one bite, including team pepperoni that wanted to go down together.
The patty was a surprise. Not many places go for the charbroiled patty. I can see why after I took a few bites. The patty's taste was okay. The charbroiled taste can be an overwhelming taste and sometimes can overtake a burger. This was okay. Not fantastic, not horrible, just okay.
The bun was a kaiser roll. It doesn't add or take away from the burger, which is acceptable. The bun did its job.
Overall this was not a good burger in the slightest. When the burger's best trait is the bun, you're not in good waters. The charbroiled taste combined with the toppings were an unnatural combination and a displeasing taste to the tongue. I kept thinking I could have a better overall burger at Burger King with the charbroiled reminder. Between the charbroiled taste, the bland sauce, and my toppings falling off, I walked away from this burger and didn't finish. When you get irritated eating, I would not bother trying it again. Thumbs down.
TOPPINGS: 3
PATTY: 3
BUN: 4
OVERALL: 3
-Nick
nick@rateaburger.com